Gunselman's Tavern Menu
Apps
Breaded Mushrooms
button mushrooms breaded and deep fried + cilantro Cajun ranch
US$9.00
Meese's Meatballs
Ground pork & beef meatballs + Italian spices + house marinara + parmesan cheese
US$10.00
Pierogi Lady Pierogi
4 potato & cheese pierogi + grilled onions + sour cream - hand crimped pierogi made with a cream cheese based dough
US$10.00
Buffala 'Rogies
5 deep fried Pierogi Lady pierogi's tossed in buffalo sauce + bleu cheese crumbles
US$10.00
Chicken Tenders
OG deep-fried marinated chicken tenders + honey mustard
US$9.00
Mozzarella Sticks
Fried Mozzarella sticks + Marinara + Parmesan cheese
US$8.00
Beer Cheese Dip
Cheddar cheese + Bertman's Original Ballpark Mustard(r) + Gunselman's Kolsch beer with giant Bavarian pretzel
US$12.00
Loaded Fries
Choose from:Truffle rosemary fries served with garlic aioli, Garlic parmesan fries(Garlic butter & parmesan cheese)Cheesy bacon fries (cheese + bacon + sour cream + scallions)
US$8.00
Ten Jumbo Chicken Wings
Choose from: Gunny spicy BBQ, Gunny Buffalo, Gunny garlic parmesan, Gunny Buffalo Ranch, teriyaki zing, sweet BBQ, Cajun dry rub, or six pepper dry rub
US$14.00
Dozen Boneless Chicken Wings
Choose from: Gunny spicy BBQ, Gunny Buffalo, Gunny garlic parmesan, Gunny Buffalo Ranch, teriyaki zing, sweet BBQ, Cajun dry rub, Atomic Hot or six pepper dry rub
US$9.00
Burgers
Just Plain Jane
Foster's Meats select top sirloin freshly ground to our specifications. Add your favorite toppings.
US$10.00
Mushroom Swiss
Grilled mushrooms & onions + Swiss cheese
US$12.00
Gunny BBQ Bacon
Spicy Gunny BBQ sauce + hickory-smoked bacon + cheddar + onion straws
US$13.00
All-American
Sunny side up egg + American cheese + hickory-smoked bacon
US$14.00
Black & Bleu
Cajun dry rub + spicy bleu cheese butter + onion straws + Gunny house-made steak sauce
US$13.00
California Style
Avocado slices + hickory-smoked bacon + Swiss cheese
US$13.00
The Beast Burger
Wagyu Beef + Bison + Wild Boar + New Zealand Elk + Lto + Beast Sauce
US$15.00
Patty Melt
Toasted marbled rye + grilled onions + Swiss cheese
US$12.00
The Big G Burger
Two Westside Market 1/2 lb patties + special sauce + lettuce + cheese + pickles + onions + brioche bun
US$15.00
Buffalo Burger
House buffalo sauce + bleu cheese crumbles + pepperjack cheese + scallions + jalapenos + bacon
US$13.00
Guardian Burger
Twin flat patties + salami + pepperoni + capicola + banana peppers + provolone + herbed olive oil + LTO
US$14.00
Soups & Salads
Gunny Cobb
Spring mix + grilled chicken + crumbled bacon + egg + tomato + crumbled bleu cheese + avocado + house-made Derby dressing
US$12.00
Classic Caesar
Chopped romaine + Parmesan cheese + tomato + croutons + Caesar dressing
US$6.00
Fall Nut Salad
Spring mix + grilled chicken + apples + candied walnuts + brie cheese + red onions + apple cider vinaigrette.
US$12.00
Buffalo Chicken Salad
Romaine + Buffalo chicken + tomatoes + celery + bleu cheese
US$12.00
Steak Soup
House recipe steak & vegetable soup
US$6.00
Side Salad
Spring mix + tomato + cheddar cheese + red onion + croutons
US$6.00
Jailhouse Chili
Best in the tri-county area, fresh beef, red beans and The Warden's secret spice packet.
US$6.00
Dinners
Irish Kevin's Paprikash
Unique vegetable & sour cream sauce + Spanish paprika + chicken thighs
US$14.00
Westside Kielbasa & Pierogi
J&J Czuchraj kielbasa + Pierogi Lady potato & cheese pierogi + grilled onions + sour cream + Cleveland Kraut
US$14.00
Cabbage & Noodles
Egg noodles + cabbage (Butter and bacon braised)
US$9.00
12oz Ribeye Steak
12Oz Hand Cut Ribeye Steak + Chef'S Veg + Redskin Mashed Potatoes (Grilled Mushroom & Onions +$2)
US$21.00
Buffalo Mac 'n' Cheese
White cheddar mac + Buffalo fried chicken + crumbled bleu cheese + tomato + scallions
US$13.00
Lobster Mac 'N' Cheese
White cheddar macaroni + 8oz Lobster claw & knuckle meat + lemon + butter + Old Bay spice
US$17.00
Fish & Chips
Beer battered cod loins + french fries + tarter sauce + coleslaw + lemon
US$14.00
Perch dinner
Panko crusted Lake Perch + French fries + Tartar sauce + Coleslaw + Lemon
US$16.00
Pork Ribeye Schnitzel
Breaded pork loin + Cleveland Kraut + redskin mashed potatoes & brown gravy
US$14.00
Grace Family Meatloaf
Family recipe meatloaf served with redskin mashed potatoes + topped with brown gravy + chef's vegetable
US$14.00
Burger of The Month
April Burger of The Month The Italian Dip
House meatball mix patty covered with melted provolone and shaved Parmesan on two pieces of garlic bread. Served with garlic Parm fries and marinara for dipping.
US$15.00
Impossible Burgers (Vegan)
Just Plain Impossible
The Impossible burger with your choice of toppings.
US$14.00
Mushroom Swiss Impossible Burger
Sauteed mushrooms, carmelized grilled onions, Swiss cheese.
US$16.00
Impossible Black & Bleu
Cajun dry rub patty, bleu cheese butter, onion straws and A1 sauce.
US$17.00
All American Impossible
Sunny side up egg, American cheese, hickory smoked bacon.
US$18.00
Big Impossible G
One pound of Impossible veggie burger. Twin 8oz Impossible patties, secret sauce, lettuce, cheese, pickles, onions on a fresh brioche bun.
US$23.00
California Style Impossible Burger
Avocado, hickory smoked bacon, and Swiss cheese.
US$17.00
Impossible Patty Melt
Impossible patty, toasted rye bread, carmelized onions, Swiss cheese.
US$16.00
Chicken Sandwiches
Just Plain Jane Chicken
Grilled chicken breast on brioche bun. Your choice of toppings.
US$10.00
Chicken Mushroom Swiss
Sauteed mushrooms, carmelized grilled onions, Swiss cheese.
US$11.00
Black & Bleu Chicken
Cajun dry rub chicken breast, bleu cheese butter, onion straws and A1 sauce.
US$13.00
California Chicken Sandwich
Grilled chicken breast, hickory smoked bacon, Swiss cheese, avocado.
US$13.00
Gunny Bacon BBQ Chicken
Gunselman's spicy BBQ sauce, hickory smoked bacon, cheddar cheese, onion straws.
US$13.00
Sandwiches
Gunnyfried Chicken Sandwich
Deep-Fried Breaded Chicken Breast + Lettuce + Tomato + Siracha Aioli
US$11.00
Corned Beef Sandwich
1/2 pound sliced corned beef + Swiss cheese + rye bread + side of Bertman Original Ball Park Mustard
US$12.00
Jumbo Corned Beef Sandwich
One pound sliced corned beef + Swiss cheese + rye bread + side of Bertman Original Ball Park Mustard
US$18.00
The Reuben
1/2 pound sliced corned beef + Swiss cheese + Cleveland Kraut + 1000 island dressing + rye bread
US$13.00
World Famous Steak Sandwich
6 oz ribeye steak + grilled mushrooms & onions + grilled mushrooms + side of Gunny steak sauce
US$15.00
Philly Cheesesteak
Shaved ribeye + grilled mushrooms + grilled peppers & onions + provolone cheese
US$12.00
Chicken Philly
Grilled chicken + grilled mushrooms + grilled peppers & onions + provolone cheese
US$11.00
Meatball Sub
Meese's meatballs + marinara sauce + mozzarella cheese on a hoagie bun
US$12.00
Meatloaf sandwich
Grilled meatloaf + onion straws + Gunny BBQ sauce
US$10.00
Fiesty italian
Salami + pepperoni + pastrami + banana peppers + provolone cheese + lettuce + tomato + onion + herbed olive oil on a hoagie bun
US$12.00
Schnitzel sandwich
Breaded pork ribeye + Cleveland kraut + sauteed onions + side of Bertman's Original Ballpark Mustard
US$13.00
Hot Cleveland Polish Boy
J&J Czuchraj spicy Polish Boy smoked sausage + coleslaw + French fries + Gunny spicy BBQ sauce on a hoagie roll
US$14.00
Sides
Bertman's(r) Brussel Sprouts
US$5.00
Redskin mashed Potatoes
US$5.00
Chef's Vegetable
US$5.00
Onion Rings SIDE ONLY
US$5.00
Sweet Potato Fries
US$5.00
Mac N' Cheese
US$5.00
SIDE House Salad
US$5.00
SIDE Caesar Salad
US$5.00
At Gunselman's Tavern, located on Lorain Rd in Fairview Park, you'll find a menu that’s as inviting as the cozy atmosphere. Whether you're in the mood for a hearty burger, crispy fries, or a savory appetizer, this tavern has something to satisfy every craving. The casual, friendly vibe pairs perfectly with the mouth-watering options on the menu, from classic comfort food to unique twists on old favorites. With generous portions and fresh ingredients, each dish is designed to make your dining experience memorable. Whether you're stopping in for a quick bite or a long, leisurely meal with friends, the Gunselman's Tavern Menu offers plenty of options that keep both regulars and first-time guests coming back for more.